Copycat Crumbl Cookie Recipes to Bake at Home 2025
Imagine walking into a bakery where every week feels like dessert heaven; that’s Crumbl. Their cookies are so big, soft, and flavorful that people line up for them every Monday just to try the new menu. In 2023 alone, Crumbl sold over 300 million cookies across the U.S., proving that these aren’t just cookies — they’re a brand.
But what if you could bring that same taste home? That’s where crumbl recipes come in; easy-to-follow versions of your favorite Crumbl cookies that taste almost identical to the original. This article will introduce you with various copycat Crumbl cookie recipes, their baking techniques and expert baking tips.
WHAT’S SPECIAL ABOUT CRUMBL COOKIES?
Crumbl started in 2017 in Logan, Utah, with just one flavor; milk chocolate chip. Today, they have over 900 stores in the U.S. and release new cookie flavors every week. That rotating menu and limited-time exclusivity make people obsessed with trying each one.
Here’s what makes Crumbl-style cookies special:
| Crumbl Feature | What Makes It Unique |
|---|---|
| Size | Each cookie weighs nearly 5.5 oz — double the average cookie. |
| Texture | Crispy edge + soft center balance. |
| Flavors | Over 250 rotating flavors and counting. |
| Presentation | Iconic pink box and frosting swirls. |
CLASSIC COPYCAT CRUMBL RECIPES
Crumbl is best known for its classic lineup; cookies so rich, soft, and thick they almost feel like mini cakes. These are the flavors that made Crumbl famous and keep fans coming back every week. Whether you’re craving the gooey Chocolate Chip or the chilled Sugar Cookie, these crumbl recipes let you bake the same indulgence right at home.
CRUMBL CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE RECIPE
This is the cookie that started it all. Crumbl’s milk chocolate chip cookie is massive; nearly 5.5 ounces per cookie and perfectly balanced with crisp edges and a soft, buttery center. The key elements include in it are semi-sweet & milk chocolate chips, sprinkle of sea salt and is slightly underbaked for a gooey center.
CRUMBL CHILLED SUGAR COOKIE RECIPE
Served cold with a creamy pink almond frosting, it’s soft, buttery, and nostalgic. It has butter shortbread style base, almond flavored frosting that is chilled to perfection. Crumbl chilled sugar cookie might be the most talked-about flavor online.
CRUMBL PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
If you love peanut butter, this crumbl cookie recipe will be your go-to. It’s thick, warm, and loaded with melty milk chocolate chips.
Key Features:
- Smooth peanut butter base.
- Studded with peanut butter & chocolate chips.
- Soft-baked with a slightly crisp top.
CINNAMON SWIRL COOKIE RECIPE
Sweet, soft, and dusted with cinnamon sugar; this cookie is Crumbl’s take on an American classic.
What Makes It Special:
- Cinnamon-sugar crust on a buttery dough.
- Swirled brown sugar frosting.
- Perfect fall and holiday flavor.
Many bakers rate this among the most accurate crumbl recipes to recreate at home — it’s simple yet feels premium.
CRUMBL RED VELVET COOKIE
This rich, vibrant cookie delivers the same warmth as red velvet cake but in cookie form.
Key Features:
- Cocoa-infused red velvet dough.
- Cream cheese frosting swirl.
- Topped with crushed red velvet crumbs.
CRUMBL COOKIES & CREAM MILKSHAKE COOKIE
Inspired by the classic Oreo milkshake, this crumbl cookie recipe blends crushed Oreos into a chocolate dough topped with cookies & cream frosting.
Why You’ll Love It:
- Creamy, cold frosting for milkshake vibes.
- Oreo chunks inside and on top.
- Perfect balance of chocolate and vanilla.
CRUMBL CLASSIC COPYCAT RECIPES RECAP
| Cookie Name | Taste Profile | Best Served | Signature Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chocolate Chip | Buttery & Gooey | Warm | Double chocolate blend |
| Chilled Sugar | Sweet & Buttery | Cold | Almond frosting |
| Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip | Nutty & Rich | Warm | Peanut butter + milk chocolate combo |
| Snickerdoodle | Cinnamon Sweet | Warm | Brown sugar frosting |
| Red Velvet | Velvety Cocoa | Warm | Cream cheese swirl |
| Cookies & Cream Milkshake | Chocolatey & Creamy | Cold | Oreo crumble top |
MOST POPULAR CRUMBL COOKIE RECIPES YOU CAN TRY AT HOME
If you’re the kind of person who refreshes Crumbl menu every Monday just to see what’s new, you’re not alone. Fans across the U.S. have fallen in love with these thick, gooey, and picture-perfect cookies; leading to thousands of crumbl cookie recipes popping up online. With over 250 rotating flavors and a community obsessed with copycats, home bakers are now recreating Crumbl’s magic right from their kitchens. Below are eight of the most popular crumbl cookie recipes that have gone viral for their spot-on taste and texture.
CRUMBL MILK CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
This is the signature cookie that built Crumbl’s empire. Soft in the middle, slightly crisp on the edges, and loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chips, it’s a cookie that feels nostalgic yet luxurious.
The secret behind this classic crumbl cookie recipe lies in its balance; using two types of flour to achieve density without dryness and melting chocolate chunks rather than chips for that signature gooey texture. It’s the perfect starting point for anyone exploring crumbl recipes at home.
CRUMBL CHILLED SUGAR COOKIE
This cookie is a social media icon. Known for its soft vanilla base and smooth pink frosting, the Chilled Sugar Cookie became one of Crumbl’s earliest viral hits on TikTok. Its almond-flavored frosting gives it that unmistakable scent and taste fans recognize instantly.
What makes this crumbl cookie recipe special is its serving temperature. The cookie is baked soft and then chilled before frosting, giving a firm top with a creamy layer underneath. Despite being discontinued from the menu, it’s still one of the most recreated crumbl recipes online because fans simply can’t get enough of it.
CRUMBL CORNBREAD COOKIE
The Cornbread Cookie is buttery, slightly gritty, and perfectly sweet, layered with honey butter glaze. This crumbl cookie recipe stands out because it’s both unique and comforting; a soft honey-infused dough baked until golden and topped with glaze that melts beautifully when warm. It’s a flavor that feels homemade but with a Crumbl-level twist.
CRUMBL PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE
The Peanut Butter Cookie is for those who crave depth in flavor. Rich, nutty, and perfectly balanced between salty and sweet, this cookie melts on your tongue like warm peanut butter fudge. A good crumbl cookie recipe for this one uses creamy peanut butter with a bit of brown sugar to enhance moisture and flavor.
CRUMBL OREO COOKIE
The Oreo Cookie combines two favorites; the iconic chocolate sandwich cookie and Crumbl’s soft dough. Crushed Oreos are blended into the dough, and the top is swirled with cream cheese frosting for that cookies-and-cream punch. This crumbl cookie recipe has been among the most downloaded and recreated ones across baking blogs.
CRUMBL BIRTHDAY CAKE COOKIE
A soft vanilla base with colorful sprinkles inside and a thick layer of frosting on top. Whether it’s the Birthday Cake (Puff Cereal) version or the Chocolate Birthday Cake spin-off, this cookie never fails to make people smile.
According to Google Trends, searches for “birthday crumbl cookie recipe” spike every May and December, proving how seasonal and emotionally connected this cookie is. It’s a reminder that some crumbl recipes don’t just taste good — they make moments feel special.
CRUMBL MOONBEAM ICECREAM COOKIE
A chilled sugar cookie topped with a swirl of creamy blue vanilla frosting and finished with a sprinkle of sparkling sugar crystals; soft, smooth, and simply out of this world. This crumbl cookie recipe is refreshing and amazing.
CRUMBL BROWNIE BATTER COOKIE
Imagine the gooey center of a brownie in cookie form. That’s exactly what Crumbl achieved with this one. The Brownie Batter Cookie is dense, rich, and perfectly chewy, topped with glossy chocolate ganache.
CRUMBL CONFETTI COOKIE
This cookie bursts with colorful sprinkles, soft vanilla dough, and creamy frosting that reminds everyone of birthday cake batter. It’s not overly sweet but gives you that nostalgic bakery taste people crave.
This crumbl cookie recipe is simple yet satisfying; using real butter, cake flour, and almond extract for that signature soft-baked texture.
CRUMBL CINNAMON ROLL COOKIE
The Cinnamon Roll Cookie features a soft, buttery base swirled with cinnamon sugar and topped with luscious cream cheese frosting that melts into every crevice. A home version of this crumbl cookie recipe requires chilling the dough before baking to keep the roll’s spiral effect intact. Warm, comforting, and addicting, it’s a staple among crumbl recipes loved by every cinnamon lover.
CRUMBL CHOCOLATE CUPCAKE COOKIE
If you can’t decide between a cupcake and a cookie, this one gives you both. The Chocolate Cupcake Cookie combines a dense chocolate base topped with a swirl of chocolate frosting and a sprinkle of chocolate crumbs for a rich, triple-layered texture.
This crumbl cookie recipe has one goal: indulgence. Each bite feels like fudge with frosting on top. Bloggers like Salt & Baker note it’s one of the easiest crumbl recipes to replicate because the frosting carries most of the flavor magic.
CRUMBL S’MORES COOKIE
The S’mores Cookie brings nostalgia to life with a chewy graham cracker base, gooey marshmallow center, and chunks of melted chocolate. The best home version of this crumbl cookie recipe often uses mini marshmallows stuffed inside the dough so they melt just enough while baking. It’s one of the most photographed crumbl recipes because of its picture-perfect, golden-brown finish.
CRUMBL BISCOFF WHITE CHIP COOKIE
A modern fan-favorite, this cookie blends creamy white chocolate chips with crushed Lotus Biscoff biscuits for a caramelized crunch in every bite. This crumbl cookie recipe mimics the signature melt-in-your-mouth texture of Crumbl’s version using cookie butter as a base.
CRUMBL PINK SUGAR COOKIE
Pretty, pink, and timeless. The Pink Sugar Cookie is another Crumbl original with soft, buttery dough and almond-flavored frosting tinted in pale pink. It was once Crumbl’s weekly must-have before its temporary retirement. This crumbl cookie recipe requires a perfect frosting-to-cookie ratio. Fans who recreate it often chill the cookies before serving, replicating that signature Crumbl coolness.
CRUMBL COOKIE DOUGH COOKIE
Crumbl’s Cookie Dough Cookie features a soft, brown sugar base topped with cookie dough pieces and chocolate chips, finished with a drizzle of frosting.
The crumbl cookie recipe version combines heat-treated flour and edible cookie dough topping to make it safe and delicious. For anyone exploring crumbl recipes at home, this one’s a must-try.
Read also: How Long Do CRUMBL Cookies Last at Room Temp, Fridge & Freezer?
BAKING TIPS & TECHNIQUES
Want your homemade crumbl cookie recipe to look and taste like the real deal? The secret lies in the details; texture, temperature, and timing. One small change can make a big difference.
Crumbl cookies are famous for being thick, chewy, and slightly gooey inside. Here’s how to get it right:
- Use high-fat butter (82% or more) for a rich flavor.
- Underbake slightly; take cookies out when the centers are just set.
- Always chill the dough for 30–60 minutes before baking for perfect shape retention.
| Tip | Why? |
|---|---|
| Chill the dough | Prevents spreading and enhances flavor |
| Use cornstarch | Keeps cookies soft for days |
| Bake at 350°F | Ideal for even browning |
| Rest 10 min after baking | Allows texture to set properly |
USE QUALITY INGREDIENTS
Just like Crumbl’s kitchen, quality defines your cookie.
- Butter: Always real, never margarine.
- Vanilla: Pure extract only — no imitation.
- Flour: Use unbleached all-purpose flour for the right density.
STORAGE AND REHEATING
Keep your cookies tasting bakery-fresh:
- Store in an airtight container for up to 3 days at room temperature.
- Microwave for 10 seconds before serving to bring back that warm, gooey texture.
- Freeze baked cookies for up to 2 months — reheat at 300°F for 5 minutes before eating.
Read also: Crumbl Spoilers and Next Week’s Menu Flavors
EXPERT INSIGHTS & PRO HACKS
Crumbl cookies may look simple, but recreating their magic at home takes smart tricks. These insights are gathered from pro bakers and tested crumbl recipes by fans across Reddit and TikTok. Here are the secrets:
- Measure by weight, not cups. Even a 10g difference in flour changes texture.
- Scoop big. Each Crumbl cookie weighs about 5.5 ounces before baking; that’s double a regular cookie.
- Rotate your tray halfway through to ensure even baking.
FROSTING & TOPING RATIOS
Frosting makes or breaks a Crumbl-style cookie. Here’s a quick guide:
| Cookie Type | Frosting Ratio | Frosting Tip |
|---|---|---|
| Sugar & Red Velvet | 1:1 | Pipe a swirl using an open star tip |
| Cheesecake Cookies | 1:2 | Keep frosting chilled before spreading |
| Chocolate Variants | 1:1.5 | Add melted chocolate for shine |
PORTION CONTROL & MINI VERSIONS
Crumbl cookies are huge — nearly 600–1,000 calories each. Want to enjoy more flavors guilt-free?
- Use ¼ of the original dough per cookie to make “mini Crumbls.”
- Reduce bake time by 2 minutes for smaller cookies.
- Perfect for parties or tasting trays!
FLAVOR RANKINGS
The Crumbl community is massive; over 1.2 million Reddit users and countless Facebook bakers share copycat versions every week. Here’s what fans say about their favorite crumbl cookie recipes.
TOP RATED FAN FAVORITES
| Rank | Cookie | What Fans Love |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Chocolate Chip | Classic, thick, buttery perfection |
| 2 | Raspberry Cheesecake | Tangy cream cheese frosting & crumb base |
| 3 | Galaxy Brownie | Chocolate overload for fudge lovers |
| 4 | Chilled Sugar Cookie | Simple but addicting vanilla frosting |
| 5 | Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip | Sweet-salty balance done right |
Read also: CRUMBL Vegan Cookies Recipe: Soft, Chewy & Dairy-Free
FAQs
Let’s answer the most-asked questions about crumbl recipes and their bakery originals.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Crumbl may have started in a small Utah kitchen, but its cookies have taken over America; and now, your kitchen too.
The beauty of these crumbl recipes is that you can experiment endlessly. Whether it’s the Red Velvet Cookie for Valentine’s Day or the Galaxy Brownie for movie nights, each bite feels like a celebration.
